I have tried out a few new pencils lately, part of my continual search for the one pencil that seems just right to me. I have been very happy with the Palominos made by California Republic (as blogged about earlier HERE), and even though they have the best graphite I have found since the Blackwing 602, they lack a certain, well, sense of style. The bright orange color, although definitely distinctive, is a little too loud for my liking. The design of the Blackwing 602 is as cool as it gets when it comes to pencils, and even though ultimately the important thing is how it writes, I find I'm still longing for a pencil that looks as good as it writes.
I have been piecing together the perfect pencil in my mind lately, exhuming the parts from the assortment of good pencils I regularly use to create the ultimate writing tool. In order to create the perfect all-around pencil I first need to harvest a few parts. My goal here is a pencil that would be highly functional for day-to-day use, comfortable for writing for longer periods of time, and not too specialized (i.e., it doesn't also have to be the best sketching pencil).
The graphite core needs to be a California Republic Palomino HB grade. I would also keep the same Cal Cedar wood from the Palomino, but loose the orange lacquer. The Palominos have a very nice professionally done finish, but I find the high finish to be a bit slippery at times.
There are plans to add an eraser to the Palominos, but I have yet to sample the new erasers. Judging from the erasers on the Golden Bears from California Republic they work well, but I would skip the orange and blue colors. Also, I find the Golden Bear erasers are a tad on the greasy side, although better than your average pencil eraser. I started using the oversize Dixon Tri-Conderoga, and these are a great pencil. The graphite is almost as nice as the Palomino and they have a nice clean working black colored eraser on them. These erasers work very well, are not smudgy or greasy, and are a nice shade of black. Here's a place to find some style, so my Frankenpencil would have the Dixon black eraser on it.
I recently bought a 2 dozen pack of regular hexagonal Ticonderoga Black pencils at Wal Mart. These have a really nice satin finish to them, it isn't the rubberized finish like the larger format Tri-Conderogas which is nice, but can get a little sticky feeling with use. I find that I love the feel of the Ticonderoga Black; it is smooth but easy to grip. So, I would add the satin finish from this pencil to my creation, and while I'm at it, I'll keep the black color as well.
Now for the shape of the barrel: The triangular barrel of the Ticonderoga Tri-Write has always been the most comfortable for me. The larger barrel thickness of the Tri-Conderoga is good, but I prefer the smaller diameter. I prefer a triangular barrel to the hexagonal, and round barrels tend to roll away, so I would harvest the barrel shape from the Tri-Write for my Frankenpencil.
As for the ferrule I suggest something simple. The ferrule design of the Blackwing was it's Achilles' heel, so I will avoid over complicating the ferrule as it could lead to an untimely demise. A triangular pencil definitely needs a triangular ferrule though, unlike the round one on the Tri-Write.
Now, how about a cool name? In that department the Blackwing and the Black Warrior have always reigned, and don't forget the Black Velvet. The Black Warrior is a pencil with a cool name, but I find the graphite core to be scratchy. How they get away with claiming they are "The World's Smoothest Writing Pencil" on the package, I'll never know. The Pink Pearl eraser that comes on the Black Warrior is very good, but the addition of the double heart logo to the pencil barrel is a definite killer of cool. I would keep the "black" part of the name for my Frankenpencil, but what to use for the second part of the name? Well, we will just have to hire a marketing team for that.
Here's a summary of the pencil parts:
- Graphite Core: Palomino HB.
- Slats: Cal Cedar.
- Eraser: Dixon Ticonderoga Black eraser.
- Finish: Black satin finish from the Dixon Ticonderoga Black.
- Barrel Shape: Triangular barrel from Ticonderoga Tri-Write.
- Ferrule: Triangular. Something simple yet nice, with as much style as possible without threatening the longevity of the pencil production.
- Name: Black Something; I'll have to get back to you on this. Or what about "Noir"?
I don't expect I will ever find a pencil that possesses all the qualities I have stitched together here, but it is fun to dream of the perfect pencil. In reality what is perfect would vary from person to person and job to job, so it would be impossible to accomplish this for everyone. Until my Frankenpencil is given life by a pencil manufacturer (It's alive, it's aliiiiiive!), I will just have to be happy with the variety of pencils I have on hand.
Recent Comments